Dog toys for every kind of player
By the Toodle team · Updated · Prices checked daily
The best dog toy is one that matches how your dog likes to play. These are the dog toys in stock at the shops we work with, grouped by kind: plush, fetch, tug, chew and puzzle toys.
At a glance
We found 32 options in stock from 5 stores, from $6.10 to $24.99.
- Lowest-priced in Plush and squeaky toys: Outward Hound Hedgehogz Plush Dog Toy, $6.10 at Only Natural Pet
- Lowest-priced in Fetch toys and balls: Boomerang Fetch Toy, 10 in, $8.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery
- Lowest-priced in Tug toys: Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy, $6.99 at GreaterGood
- Lowest-priced in Chew toys: Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy, $9.99 at Only Natural Pet
- Lowest-priced in Treat, puzzle and foraging toys: KONG Classic Dog Toy, $11.96 at Only Natural Pet
How we picked
- Toys made for dogs
- In stock with a current price
- Grouped by kind, then by price
Listed from the lowest price. Prices and stock come from each store and are checked through the day. We haven't tested these products ourselves; the facts come from each maker's listing. Stores may pay Toodle a commission; that never changes what's listed or the order. How Toodle makes money
Choose a toy that's too big to swallow, and supervise play. No toy is indestructible.
Plush and squeaky toys
1. Outward Hound
Outward Hound Hedgehogz Plush Dog Toy
Squeaky plush hedgehog toy for dogs.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$6.10 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 8 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
2. Scoochie
Scoochzilla Bacon Toy, 13 in
A 13 in plush bacon strip dog toy.
$6.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
3. Scoochie
Scoochzilla French Fry Toy
A plush french fries dog toy.
$6.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
4. ZippyPaws
Donutz Plush Toy
A plush donut squeaky toy, in chocolate or blueberry frosting.
- 3 sizes
- 2 colors
$7.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · Blueberry · JuniorPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
5. ZippyPaws
Nomnomz Pineapple
A plush pineapple squeaky toy.
$8.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
6. Pet Lou
Dotty Friends Teddy Bear
A plush teddy bear squeaky toy, in a 7 in pocket size or 13 in.
- 2 sizes
$9.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · 7 inPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
7. Pet Lou
Pastel Pals Warthog, 8 in
An 8 in pastel plush warthog squeaky toy.
$9.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
8. Spunky Pup
Spunky Bear Squeaky Toy
A plush bear with a squeaker, medium size.
$9.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
9. ZippyPaws
Ecozippy Corduroy Critter
A corduroy plush squeaky toy, as a bear, moose or beetle.
- 3 colors
$10.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · BeetlePrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
10. FuzzYard
Giggles Mushroom Fun-Guy
A plush mushroom squeaky toy.
$10.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
11. PetLou
Strawberry Squeaker Dog Toy
An 8-inch plush strawberry with a hidden squeaker, for tossing, tugging and carrying.
$10.99 at GreaterGoodPrice checked 3 hours ago
Buy at GreaterGood
12. Pet Lou
Trick or Treat Pals, 7 in
A pair of 7 in Halloween plush toys, in three sets.
- 3 colors
$10.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · Drake & FrankPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
Fetch toys and balls
13. Coastal Pet
Boomerang Fetch Toy, 10 in
A 10 in soft boomerang for throwing and fetching.
$8.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
14. Pet Lou
Dog Ball, 8 in
An 8 in plush ball with a dog face.
$12.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
15. Coastal Pet
Fox Fetch Toy with Rope, 14 in
A 14 in plush fox with a rope to throw it by.
$12.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
16. Pet Lou
Pig Ball, 8 in
An 8 in plush ball with a pig face.
$12.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
17. K9 Sport Sack
Too Big to Chew Tennis Ball
A 9 in felt tennis ball, too big for a dog to fit in their mouth, for chasing, pushing and rolling around.
$14.95 at K9 Sport SackPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at K9 Sport Sack
18. Sea Bags
Floating Rope Dog Toy
A monkey-fist knot on a length of rugged Maine lobster-trap rope.
$15.00 at Sea Bags · YellowPrice checked 8 hours ago
Buy at Sea Bags
19. Ruff Dawg
Ruff Dawg K9 Flyer Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy
A flexible rubber flying disc for supervised fetch with dogs.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$16.76 at Only Natural Pet · K9 Junior Flyer / AssortedPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
20. Pet Lou
EZ Squeaky Ball Twin Pack, 4 in
Two 4 in Halloween squeaky balls, as Pumpstein or Batmmy.
- 2 colors
$18.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · PumpsteinPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
21. RuffWear
RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Ball Toy
A treat-fillable dog ball made with repurposed webbing.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$19.99 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
Tug toys
22. Jolly Pets
Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy
A ladybug tug toy that squeaks when both ends are pulled.
$6.99 at GreaterGoodPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at GreaterGood
23. Coastal Pet
Duck Tug Toy, 13 in
A 13 in plush duck made for tug games.
$12.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
24. RuffWear
RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Tug Toy
A dog tug toy made with repurposed yarn and webbing.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$24.99 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
Chew toys
25. Woof
Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy
A firm, plant-based dog chew toy offered in two shapes and three sizes.
- Sizes Small to Large
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$9.99 at Only Natural Pet · Antler / SmallPrice checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
26. Tuffy
Silly Squeaker Beer Can, Smella Arpaw
A squeaky rubber parody beer can dog toy.
$10.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
27. Spunky Pup
Double Wall Hydrant
A rubber fire hydrant chew toy with a double wall, made in the USA.
- Sizes Small to Large
$11.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · SmallPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
28. Spunky Pup
The Tire Rubber Toy
A tire-shaped chew and fetch toy made in the USA from reclaimed rubber.
- Sizes Small to Large
$11.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · SmallPrice checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
Treat, puzzle and foraging toys
29. KONG
KONG Classic Dog Toy
Natural rubber chew toy that can be stuffed with treats.
- Sizes Medium to Large
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$11.96 at Only Natural Pet · MediumPrice checked 12 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
30. Tall Tails
Tall Tails Silicone Foraging Mat for Dogs
A silicone foraging mat for serving suitable wet or dry dog food.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$21.15 at Only Natural Pet · BeesPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
31. WOOF
WOOF Pupsicle Treat Toy
Refillable ball toy that holds a frozen treat.
- Fits dogs 25–75 lb
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$21.49 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 8 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
32. Stashios
Stashios Soothing Saucer Liquid Treat Dispensing Toy for Dogs & Cats
A liquid-treat dispensing enrichment toy for dogs and cats.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$24.99 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
Compare them side by side
| Product | Kind | Price | Store |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outward Hound Hedgehogz Plush Dog Toy | Plush and squeaky toys | $6.10 | Only Natural Pet |
| Scoochzilla Bacon Toy, 13 in | Plush and squeaky toys | $6.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Scoochzilla French Fry Toy | Plush and squeaky toys | $6.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Donutz Plush Toy | Plush and squeaky toys | $7.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Nomnomz Pineapple | Plush and squeaky toys | $8.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Dotty Friends Teddy Bear | Plush and squeaky toys | $9.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Pastel Pals Warthog, 8 in | Plush and squeaky toys | $9.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Spunky Bear Squeaky Toy | Plush and squeaky toys | $9.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Ecozippy Corduroy Critter | Plush and squeaky toys | $10.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Giggles Mushroom Fun-Guy | Plush and squeaky toys | $10.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Strawberry Squeaker Dog Toy | Plush and squeaky toys | $10.99 | GreaterGood |
| Trick or Treat Pals, 7 in | Plush and squeaky toys | $10.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Boomerang Fetch Toy, 10 in | Fetch toys and balls | $8.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Dog Ball, 8 in | Fetch toys and balls | $12.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Fox Fetch Toy with Rope, 14 in | Fetch toys and balls | $12.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Pig Ball, 8 in | Fetch toys and balls | $12.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Too Big to Chew Tennis Ball | Fetch toys and balls | $14.95 | K9 Sport Sack |
| Floating Rope Dog Toy | Fetch toys and balls | $15 | Sea Bags |
| Ruff Dawg K9 Flyer Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy | Fetch toys and balls | $16.76 | Only Natural Pet |
| EZ Squeaky Ball Twin Pack, 4 in | Fetch toys and balls | $18.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Ball Toy | Fetch toys and balls | $19.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy | Tug toys | $6.99 | GreaterGood |
| Duck Tug Toy, 13 in | Tug toys | $12.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Tug Toy | Tug toys | $24.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy | Chew toys | $9.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Silly Squeaker Beer Can, Smella Arpaw | Chew toys | $10.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Double Wall Hydrant | Chew toys | $11.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| The Tire Rubber Toy | Chew toys | $11.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| KONG Classic Dog Toy | Treat, puzzle and foraging toys | $11.96 | Only Natural Pet |
| Tall Tails Silicone Foraging Mat for Dogs | Treat, puzzle and foraging toys | $21.15 | Only Natural Pet |
| WOOF Pupsicle Treat Toy | Treat, puzzle and foraging toys | $21.49 | Only Natural Pet |
| Stashios Soothing Saucer Liquid Treat Dispensing Toy for Dogs & Cats | Treat, puzzle and foraging toys | $24.99 | Only Natural Pet |
Match the toy to how your dog plays
Some dogs love to carry and snuggle soft toys, some live for fetch, and some just want to chew. Plush toys suit gentle players and carriers. Balls, discs and rope toys suit fetchers. Tug toys are for dogs who love a game of pull with you. Firm rubber toys are for chewers, and treat and puzzle toys keep a dog busy on their own.
Picking the right size
A toy should be too big to swallow: a ball should be larger than your dog's mouth can close around. Many toys come in sizes by dog weight; size up if your dog is between sizes.
Toys and supervision
No toy is indestructible. Supervise play with new toys, take away plush toys once the seams start to go, and throw out anything small enough to swallow. Rotating a handful of toys each week keeps them feeling new.
Questions
- What toys are best for dogs that destroy everything?
- Firm rubber chew toys hold up best. Plush toys, even tough ones, can be torn apart, so supervise play with them.
- How many toys does a dog need?
- A few of different kinds, such as something to chew, something to fetch and something soft, rotated every week or so, keeps toys interesting.
- Are squeaky toys safe?
- Yes, with supervision. Take the toy away once it's torn, since squeakers and stuffing can be swallowed.