Tough dog toys for strong chewers
By the Toodle team · Updated · Prices checked daily
If your dog destroys plush toys in minutes, these are tougher options: rubber chew toys, tug toys and rubber fetch toys in stock at the shops we work with.
At a glance
We found 9 options in stock from 3 stores, from $6.99 to $24.99.
- Lowest-priced in Rubber chew toys: Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy, $9.99 at Only Natural Pet
- Lowest-priced in Tug toys: Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy, $6.99 at GreaterGood
- Lowest-priced in Fetch toys: Ruff Dawg K9 Flyer Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy, $16.76 at Only Natural Pet
How we picked
- Rubber chew toys, tug toys and rubber fetch toys for dogs (no plush)
- In stock with a current price
- Grouped by kind
Listed from the lowest price. Prices and stock come from each store and are checked through the day. We haven't tested these products ourselves; the facts come from each maker's listing. Stores may pay Toodle a commission; that never changes what's listed or the order. How Toodle makes money
Supervise play and choose a size your dog can't swallow.
Rubber chew toys
1. Woof
Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy
A firm, plant-based dog chew toy offered in two shapes and three sizes.
- Sizes Small to Large
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$9.99 at Only Natural Pet · Antler / SmallPrice checked 9 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
2. Tuffy
Silly Squeaker Beer Can, Smella Arpaw
A squeaky rubber parody beer can dog toy.
$10.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
3. KONG
KONG Classic Dog Toy
Natural rubber chew toy that can be stuffed with treats.
- Sizes Medium to Large
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$11.96 at Only Natural Pet · MediumPrice checked 1 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
4. Spunky Pup
Double Wall Hydrant
A rubber fire hydrant chew toy with a double wall, made in the USA.
- Sizes Small to Large
$11.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · SmallPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
5. Spunky Pup
The Tire Rubber Toy
A tire-shaped chew and fetch toy made in the USA from reclaimed rubber.
- Sizes Small to Large
$11.99 at Doodle Doo Bakery · SmallPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
Tug toys
6. Jolly Pets
Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy
A ladybug tug toy that squeaks when both ends are pulled.
$6.99 at GreaterGoodPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at GreaterGood
7. Coastal Pet
Duck Tug Toy, 13 in
A 13 in plush duck made for tug games.
$12.99 at Doodle Doo BakeryPrice checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Doodle Doo Bakery
8. RuffWear
RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Tug Toy
A dog tug toy made with repurposed yarn and webbing.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$24.99 at Only Natural PetPrice checked 9 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
Fetch toys
9. Ruff Dawg
Ruff Dawg K9 Flyer Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy
A flexible rubber flying disc for supervised fetch with dogs.
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$16.76 at Only Natural Pet · K9 Junior Flyer / AssortedPrice checked 8 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
Compare them side by side
| Product | Kind | Price | Store |
|---|---|---|---|
| Woof HonestChew Ultra Tough Plant Based Dog Chew Toy | Rubber chew toys | $9.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Silly Squeaker Beer Can, Smella Arpaw | Rubber chew toys | $10.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| KONG Classic Dog Toy | Rubber chew toys | $11.96 | Only Natural Pet |
| Double Wall Hydrant | Rubber chew toys | $11.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| The Tire Rubber Toy | Rubber chew toys | $11.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| Jolly Pets Jolly Tug Insect Dog Toy | Tug toys | $6.99 | GreaterGood |
| Duck Tug Toy, 13 in | Tug toys | $12.99 | Doodle Doo Bakery |
| RuffWear Webbing Remix Dog Tug Toy | Tug toys | $24.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Ruff Dawg K9 Flyer Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy | Fetch toys | $16.76 | Only Natural Pet |
No toy is indestructible
Even the toughest toy can be worn down. Supervise play, check toys for cracks and loose pieces, and replace them when they're damaged.
Pick the right size
Choose a toy too big to swallow, and size up for strong chewers. Firm rubber is usually the longest-lasting material.
Stuff it for longer play
Hollow rubber toys can be stuffed with treats or food, and frozen, to keep a chewer busy for much longer.
Questions
- What toys last longest for heavy chewers?
- Firm rubber chew toys usually last longest. Avoid plush for strong chewers.
- Are tug toys safe?
- Yes, with supervision. Let your dog win sometimes, and teach a "drop it" cue.
- How do I know when to throw a toy away?
- When it's cracked, has pieces coming off or is small enough to swallow.