Pet food and treat variety packs
By the Toodle team · Updated · Prices checked daily
Not sure what your pet will like? Variety packs and sampler boxes let you try several recipes before committing. These are the ones in stock at the shops we work with.
At a glance
We found 8 options in stock from 3 stores, from $3.99 to $99.99.
- Lowest-priced in For dogs: Nulo Signature Stew Small Breed Dog Food 2.8 oz, $23.99 at Only Natural Pet
- Lowest-priced in For cats: Fussie Cat Puree Cat Treat, $3.99 at Only Natural Pet
How we picked
- Food and treat variety packs, samplers and taste tests for dogs and cats
- In stock with a current price
- Grouped by pet
Listed from the lowest price. Prices and stock come from each store and are checked through the day. We haven't tested these products ourselves; the facts come from each maker's listing. Stores may pay Toodle a commission; that never changes what's listed or the order. How Toodle makes money
For dogs
1. Nulo
Nulo Signature Stew Small Breed Dog Food 2.8 oz
Wet dog food from Nulo.
- 4 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$23.99 at Only Natural Pet · Variety Pack (Case of 12)Price checked 7 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
2. Dr. Marty
Dr. Marty Nature's Blend Wet Dog Food in Turkey Bone Broth
Wet dog food in turkey bone broth, with Essential Wellness, Radiant Select and Sensitivity Select recipes plus a variety pack.
- 4 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$47.99 at Only Natural Pet · Essential Wellness 6.3 oz Case of 12Price checked 8 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
3. PawCo
Fresh Food Variety Box
One of each GreenBites recipe plus two LuxBites, to find the plant-based fresh recipe your dog likes best.
- Free shipping over $40 at PawCo
$68.99 at PawCoPrice checked 9 hours ago
Buy at PawCo
4. PawCo
Ultimate Variety Box
A sampler of the whole PawCo range: four GreenBites, one LuxBites, one InstaBites, and an Original Magic Cookie, Magic Topper and Magic Bar.
- Free shipping over $40 at PawCo
$99.99 at PawCoPrice checked 9 hours ago
Buy at PawCo
For cats
5. Fussie Cat
Fussie Cat Puree Cat Treat
Smooth cat purée treats in individual tubes.
- 2 sizes
- 18 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$3.99 at Only Natural Pet · Tuna with Salmon / 4 Pack 0.5 ozPrice checked 5 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
6. Tiki Cat
Tiki Cat Stix Lickable Mousse Cat Treats
Lickable mousse cat treats for serving directly or as a topper.
- 4 sizes
- 6 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$5.49 at Only Natural Pet · Chicken / 3 oz (12 Pack)Price checked 6 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
7. The Honest Kitchen
The Honest Kitchen Mousse with Goat's Milk Wet Cat Food
Smooth wet cat food made with goat’s milk.
- 2 sizes
- 4 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Only Natural Pet
$19.59 at Only Natural Pet · Variety Pack / 2.8 oz Case of 8Price checked 4 hours ago
Buy at Only Natural Pet
8. Tuft + Paw
Really Great Cat Food
Wet cat food stews in three recipes, sold in 12-packs, plus a 6-pack Taste Test with two of each recipe.
- 2 sizes
- 4 flavors
- Free shipping over $49 at Tuft + Paw
$24.00 at Tuft + Paw · Taste Test (2 of each) / 6-packPrice checked 10 hours ago
Buy at Tuft + Paw
Compare them side by side
| Product | Kind | Price | Store |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nulo Signature Stew Small Breed Dog Food 2.8 oz | For dogs | $23.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Dr. Marty Nature's Blend Wet Dog Food in Turkey Bone Broth | For dogs | $47.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Fresh Food Variety Box | For dogs | $68.99 | PawCo |
| Ultimate Variety Box | For dogs | $99.99 | PawCo |
| Fussie Cat Puree Cat Treat | For cats | $3.99 | Only Natural Pet |
| Tiki Cat Stix Lickable Mousse Cat Treats | For cats | $5.49 | Only Natural Pet |
| The Honest Kitchen Mousse with Goat's Milk Wet Cat Food | For cats | $19.59 | Only Natural Pet |
| Really Great Cat Food | For cats | $24 | Tuft + Paw |
Finding what a picky eater likes
Variety packs let you see which flavors and textures your pet prefers. Note the favorites, then buy those in bigger packs.
Switching gradually
Even when trying samples, introduce new foods slowly and mix them with your pet's usual food to avoid upset stomachs.
Questions
- Why buy a variety pack?
- To find your pet's favorites before buying a full case.
- Can I switch foods every day with a variety pack?
- Many pets do fine with variety within the same brand, but introduce new foods gradually at first.
- Are treat variety packs good for training?
- Yes: having a few flavors keeps rewards interesting.